Screening Kya Kehna in the context of the Scarlett letter
1.What are the names of the protagonists in both the works?
Ans:- in the novel protagonist is Hester, and in movie kya kehna is priya.
Ans:- in the novel protagonist is Hester, and in movie kya kehna is priya.
2.Write their story in brief.
Ans:- scarlet letter:-
In this novel it describe about Adulteruness. Haster was in jail by Dimsdail Because he was one that haster was in trouble. Haster was married woman but her husband was not with her, so haster was alone. And Dimsdail fall in love with Hester. But that was illegal, after knowing that this was illegal, they make relationship and she becomes Pragenant. So in society rules they can't accept and they against Hester, so in society way of looking like this sin done by only Hester, because people even never know about that man. And at the end they live happily.
Ans:- scarlet letter:-
In this novel it describe about Adulteruness. Haster was in jail by Dimsdail Because he was one that haster was in trouble. Haster was married woman but her husband was not with her, so haster was alone. And Dimsdail fall in love with Hester. But that was illegal, after knowing that this was illegal, they make relationship and she becomes Pragenant. So in society rules they can't accept and they against Hester, so in society way of looking like this sin done by only Hester, because people even never know about that man. And at the end they live happily.
Kya kehna:-
Priya falls in love with Rahul, a womanizer, who jilts her and leaves her when she falls pregnant. However, when all ostracize her, Ajay, her best friend, supports her and helps her through it all.
Priya falls in love with Rahul, a womanizer, who jilts her and leaves her when she falls pregnant. However, when all ostracize her, Ajay, her best friend, supports her and helps her through it all.
3.What is the role played by society in Hester’s life?
Ans:- in old people's mind we never can change and their rules also, so we have to follow that rules for Better life, for live happily, kind of things. So in Hester life she wanted to live happily but with partner but her husband was not their, so she think about other man in her life, for only sake of happy life. But this was against people, society, rules. So we find all side was negative path come from Hester.
Ans:- in old people's mind we never can change and their rules also, so we have to follow that rules for Better life, for live happily, kind of things. So in Hester life she wanted to live happily but with partner but her husband was not their, so she think about other man in her life, for only sake of happy life. But this was against people, society, rules. So we find all side was negative path come from Hester.
4.What is the role played by society in Priya’s life?
Ans:- it's not as negative way but some level she faced problems from Society's questions. Because of Relationship in under the mature age. In movie one drama prepare that was about priya's life so after tell about truth society feels like it is right or wrong. So at the end priya decided to marries with her friend.
Ans:- it's not as negative way but some level she faced problems from Society's questions. Because of Relationship in under the mature age. In movie one drama prepare that was about priya's life so after tell about truth society feels like it is right or wrong. So at the end priya decided to marries with her friend.
5.Compare and contrast the male characters, Roger Chillingworth, Arthur Dimmesdale, Rahul, and Ajay.
Ans:- the characters of novel and film's was different in their level, it's contrast that we find in both, in movie as well as in novel. In novel Chillingworth was husband of Hester, and Dimmesdale was lover. In movie rahul was lover but after knowing about pregnancy he leave priya, at the end her friend ajay decided to marries with priya, but in that marriage rahul come for priya, because he feels guilty.
Ans:- the characters of novel and film's was different in their level, it's contrast that we find in both, in movie as well as in novel. In novel Chillingworth was husband of Hester, and Dimmesdale was lover. In movie rahul was lover but after knowing about pregnancy he leave priya, at the end her friend ajay decided to marries with priya, but in that marriage rahul come for priya, because he feels guilty.
6.Compare and contrast ‘The scaffold scene in The Scarlet Letter’ and ‘a year-end performance in Kya Kehna in which a group of students performs a play on Priya and her pregnancy’.
Ans:- In both the things are some height was same but not as all the problem. Thing is that in Scarlett letter the people was narrow minded, that we know by time duration. While in kya kehna people are in modern time duration, that was important thing for both scene. Like one of Hester was alone and against all the people Strictly. While in kya kehna people watch the truth and they think their own way to side of modern time.
Ans:- In both the things are some height was same but not as all the problem. Thing is that in Scarlett letter the people was narrow minded, that we know by time duration. While in kya kehna people are in modern time duration, that was important thing for both scene. Like one of Hester was alone and against all the people Strictly. While in kya kehna people watch the truth and they think their own way to side of modern time.
7.What are the reasons that Arthur Dimmesdale and Rahul do not come forward to accept their fatherhood? How do you they differ and what are the similarities?
Ans:- like in Scarlett letter Dimmesdale was lover and also a priest in Church, so he think about his position, and what people think about that man, was important, but he also feels for Hester, but in front of society his reputation was important so he not announced his own name on that scene. In kya kehna movie rahul was Womanizer man, so this was his work, but after he leave priya, at the end he realized about that fault. But Priya can't accept him.
Ans:- like in Scarlett letter Dimmesdale was lover and also a priest in Church, so he think about his position, and what people think about that man, was important, but he also feels for Hester, but in front of society his reputation was important so he not announced his own name on that scene. In kya kehna movie rahul was Womanizer man, so this was his work, but after he leave priya, at the end he realized about that fault. But Priya can't accept him.
8.What is the role played by Chillingworth in Hester’s life? Why do you think he wanted to take revenge on Hester and Dimmesdale?
Chillingworth is husband of Hester.
Ans:- why not, we know that Chillingworth was husband of haster, but what he done? He goes somewhere and here Hester was alone live her life. If he was here with Hester this problem can't raise. Because of loneliness she love another man, and after chilled he was come for what? We know that Chillingworth wanted to take revenge with Dimmesdale, was good as Chillingworth side but not haster side. He take wanted to take revenge as husband side only, not for any other reason.
Chillingworth is husband of Hester.
Ans:- why not, we know that Chillingworth was husband of haster, but what he done? He goes somewhere and here Hester was alone live her life. If he was here with Hester this problem can't raise. Because of loneliness she love another man, and after chilled he was come for what? We know that Chillingworth wanted to take revenge with Dimmesdale, was good as Chillingworth side but not haster side. He take wanted to take revenge as husband side only, not for any other reason.
9.What is the role played by Rahul’s mother in Priya’s life? Why do you think she wants to take revenge on Priya?
Ans:-Rahul belong to high class family so his mother didn’t accept Priya as daughter in law and she wanted to take revenge on Priya because she believed her son isn’t doing wrong thing at the first meeting even Priya's brother bit her son and she believed Priya is not their status girl.
Ans:-Rahul belong to high class family so his mother didn’t accept Priya as daughter in law and she wanted to take revenge on Priya because she believed her son isn’t doing wrong thing at the first meeting even Priya's brother bit her son and she believed Priya is not their status girl.
10.Write a note on class difference in Kya Kehna.
Ans:- So, in the movie we find that priya belongs to middle class and rahul belongs to upper class, so the problem of class rahul was not accept priya also Rahul's mother was not accept this relationship, so this conflict imerge in this movie.
Ans:- So, in the movie we find that priya belongs to middle class and rahul belongs to upper class, so the problem of class rahul was not accept priya also Rahul's mother was not accept this relationship, so this conflict imerge in this movie.
11.Why do you think the director has lifted the character of Ajay to the ideal state? Is it possible in real life? What are the reasons of your YES or NO?
Ans:- it's not about ideal state of ajay that lifted by director, it's about what society think is important. So in real life it was problematic but not as higher level because in today's time we also accept second marries with child after divorce with one.
Ans:- it's not about ideal state of ajay that lifted by director, it's about what society think is important. So in real life it was problematic but not as higher level because in today's time we also accept second marries with child after divorce with one.
12.How do you see Hester and Priya as individuals?
Ans:- as individual they both are different from each other, because as time duration, was one thing. Also the narrow minded people that faced Hester but not faced priya because time, and what think people is important. It's not about one is powerful and second not, both are powerful but problem was time.
Ans:- as individual they both are different from each other, because as time duration, was one thing. Also the narrow minded people that faced Hester but not faced priya because time, and what think people is important. It's not about one is powerful and second not, both are powerful but problem was time.
13. Write a critical note on the end of the movie and the novel. Why do you think the novelist has not given happy ending?
Ans:- no, it gave happy ending in both. One side in Scarlett letter Hester, Dimmesdale and their child live happily and leave that village. Also in movie rahul accept his fault but priya now happy with ajay rather than rahul. So yes it's happy ending.
Ans:- no, it gave happy ending in both. One side in Scarlett letter Hester, Dimmesdale and their child live happily and leave that village. Also in movie rahul accept his fault but priya now happy with ajay rather than rahul. So yes it's happy ending.
Comments
Post a Comment